London Internet Church

Online community of the London Internet Church

The Superiority Of Theism Part 2: The Refutation Of Unbelief

Portraying themselves as erudite and sophisticated, the the co-called "cultured despisers of religion" attempt to trip up Christianity right out of the starting gate. Fortunately, Geisler and Turek provide the equivalent of intellectual judo in the form of a number of easily-mastered tactics that can deflect and even redirect the attacks of even the most degreed skeptics.

Foremost among these is the Road Runner Tactic. Named after the famous Looney Tune character, the Road Runner Tactic shows that often the loftiest of notions upheld in secular academia provide no solid ground to stand on, bringing to mind the scenes where Wiley Coyote went over the cliff in these animated adventures because these ideas have the ground pulled out from under them as a result of being self-defeating and self-referentially incoherent (39).

For example, entire academic specialties base their justification for existence (and thus funding) on the assertion that "There are no absolutes". By this, a variety of intellectuals ranging from anthropologists to philosophers to literary theorists contend that no standard exists above or apart from the culture in which it is utilized and as such cannot be used to judge another society.

However, this is itself formulated as an absolute applicable in all circumstances. If one holds to the position in all situations, one has by definition refuted the position by inadvertently holding that absolutes do exist. And if this one can exist, why cannot others be discovered as the mind propositionally, existentially, and experimentally struggles to comprehend the inner and outer universes?

As one gazes outward from the self, among the first things one discovers is that something as a totality exists. And as with most issues in this contentious era in which we live, two philosophical divisions have formed regarding explanations how the things around us originally came to be.

A number of the foremost thinkers of Greek philosophy and the scribes of Hebrew revelation contend that the world and everything we see in it was ultimately caused by something from beyond that was complete in itself. Known as the cosmological argument, the justification for its conclusion can be stated in the following manner: “(1) Everything that had a beginning had a cause. (2) The universe had a beginning. (3) Therefore, the universe had a cause (75).”

In the early modern period before the development of a level of science and technology sophisticated enough to probe the very composition of the universe itself, philosophical counterparts to the traditional theistic conclusions arose. For example, opponents of the cosmological argument retorted that the conclusions calling for an “unmoved mover” were merely that of a personal preference and that an infinite regress backwards into eternity past was just as rationally valid as that of a moment of creation. Advocates of this position named it the “Steady State Theory” as it contends, as Carl Sagan would put it, that the universe is all there is, was, or ever will be.

While both the traditional cosmological argument with its starting point and the steady state theory with its assertion that things now are pretty much as they have always been might be coherent with the assumptions of those expounding them, the validity of each as a mental construct must be determined by how well they fit with the evidence at hand. With the advance of empirical science, one theory at this time clearly pulls ahead in terms of common sense and rational consistency.

By Frederick Meekins

Bibliography:

Norman Geisler and Frank Turek. “I Don't Have Enough Faith To Be An Atheist.”

Views: 17

Comment

You need to be a member of London Internet Church to add comments!

Join London Internet Church

Translate this page

To find a church near you, please put in your postcode:

Latest Activity

Fr. John-Francis FRIENDSHIP SMMS commented on Fr. John-Francis FRIENDSHIP SMMS's group COMPASSIONATE HEARTS of JESUS and MARY
"‘[Is] the full emergence of the glory of the mind of Christ. The alternative orthodoxy begins in a view that God is not opposed to us; God is for us. How is God served by people who fail to germinate? God is rapturously delighted in every…"
19 hours ago
Fr. John-Francis FRIENDSHIP SMMS commented on Fr. John-Francis FRIENDSHIP SMMS's group COMPASSIONATE HEARTS of JESUS and MARY
"In the past week 140 people killed by terrorists around the world. During this month of Ramadan we pray for salaam https://www.charterforcompassion.org/you-care-so-much …"
yesterday
Fr. John-Francis FRIENDSHIP SMMS commented on Fr. John-Francis FRIENDSHIP SMMS's group COMPASSIONATE HEARTS of JESUS and MARY
"God loves me as I am but he loves me too much to leave me that way' (Quoted by David Francis D. (Comp CHJM)"
Saturday
Fr. John-Francis FRIENDSHIP SMMS commented on Fr. John-Francis FRIENDSHIP SMMS's group COMPASSIONATE HEARTS of JESUS and MARY
"Some thoughts on the problem of forgiving those who sin against others: http://cchjm.org/forgiving-those-who-sin-against-others/"
Friday
Fr. John-Francis FRIENDSHIP SMMS commented on Fr. John-Francis FRIENDSHIP SMMS's group COMPASSIONATE HEARTS of JESUS and MARY
"Soften our hearts that evil may be overcome and we may learn compassion."
May 23
Fr. John-Francis FRIENDSHIP SMMS commented on Fr. John-Francis FRIENDSHIP SMMS's group COMPASSIONATE HEARTS of JESUS and MARY
""We can be sure we are in God only when the one who claims to be living in Him is living the same kind of life as Christ lived." (1 John the Divine 2)"
May 22
Fr. John-Francis FRIENDSHIP SMMS commented on Phil and Margaret Brown.'s group Prayer Group
"Just joined the Internet church and pleased to be a member living in South East London."
May 21
Fr. John-Francis FRIENDSHIP SMMS joined Phil and Margaret Brown.'s group
Thumbnail

Prayer Group

A place to pray together and to consider thepower of prayer.See More
May 21

Badge

Loading…

© 2017   Created by Admin at LIC (network creator).   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service